Make Mine Freedom
- Publication date
- Digitizing sponsor
- Harding College (Searcy, Arkansas)
The end of World War II did not bring peace at home. Nuclear anxiety, anti-Communism and international political realignments fueled the Cold War and turned our country's media landscape into a battleground. In the press, on the radio, and increasingly through the newly emerging medium of television, business and labor struggled for power over the national consciousness. Seeking a prize worth much more than public consent, these opposing forces fought to redefine the economic structure of the nation.
To most working people, postwar "normalcy" meant a final farewell to Depression-induced privation, access to consumer goods unavailable during the war years, and a redistribution of the economic pie through the newly powerful labor movement. To business, however, the end of hostilities promised freedom from New Deal liberalism. Corporations sought an end to planning and government influence, to communist, socialist and labor movements, and above all, shrinkage of the public sector, swollen in sixteen years of economic depression and war. Both sides characterized their points of view as patriotic and their opponents as un-American.
Business fought for influence through organizations like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers. Their intentions were presented as lofty and neutral: to educate Americans about our economic system and its benefits. Launching a giant propaganda offensive, these organizations pumped out press releases, published books, organized public and private meetings, bought advertising (for examples, see "The Pursuit of Profit" and "Freedom of Choice" supplements on this disc) and produced motion pictures.
One institution most anxious to spread the news about capitalism was the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, founded by the former chairman of General Motors. The Sloan Foundation funded a small institution (the pro-free enterprise, staunchly anti-Communist Harding College in Searcy, Arkansas, which hired John Sutherland Productions, Inc. as producer) to produce a series of nine "short cartoon films, in color, which would portray simple economic truths about the American system of production and distribution in an interesting and entertaining manner." A series of grants totaling $597,870 was made to Harding College, $150,000 of this contributed by the Maurice and Laura Falk Foundation of Pittsburgh. The films were intended both for showing in theaters, schools, at community group meetings and in workplaces, often at lunchtime screenings in factories. Ironically, this effort was made feasible by a Federal government initiative: the distribution of war surplus 16mm projectors to educational and nonprofit organizations.
There was nothing new about the idea of reaching working people on the job. As an idea, "luncheon movies" date back to the 'teens, when John Patterson of National Cash Register in Dayton, Ohio pursued what were then advanced media forms to reach NCR employees with messages of inspiration, training and control. During the Depression, companies undergoing union organizing campaigns took every opportunity to reach their workers with anti-union messages, morning, noon and night. As Business Screen (Vol. 10, No. 1, 1949) said, "During the war, 62% of large U.S. employers made use of incentive or employee attitude motion pictures. Today, that figure has dropped to 35%. Isn't it reasonable to believe that a mass return to employee film programs would help pave the way for smoother labor-management relations? And at 50c a year per employee, or even two or three dollars, wouldn't it be cheaper than a strike ending in a 12-1/2c an hour pay raise?" (See "Movie Day in Your Plant" in the Archive section on this disc.)
But Sloan's project was about more than smoother labor-management relations. Although the Harding College films purported to be relaxed, humorous explanations of how America's economy works, they sought both to discredit anti-capitalist ideas and explain why our system worked better than any conceivable alternative. Although the apparent collapse of socialism around the world in the late 1980s may make these films seem prophetic today, such ideas weren't taken for granted in the postwar climate.
Make Mine Freedom links patriotism with free enterprise and freedom with prosperity. "Working together to produce an ever-greater abundance of material and spiritual values for all. That is the secret of American prosperity." "Working together," of course, is a dishonest concept when used to describe communities whose interests differ.
Unlike such films as Greyhound's upfront patriotic lump-in-the-throater Freedom Highway (on The Uncharted Landscape disc), Make Mine Freedom employs a "stealth" strategy. Self-deprecating humor prevails, perhaps because the films were made to play before distracted and highly skeptical audiences, and the targets of this humor include our consumer culture and the dubious innovations it creates.
Specific ideologies, whether Communism, socialism, fascism or capitalism, aren't mentioned. Instead, "Isms" and "imported doubletalk" are mentioned dismissively. "Ism will cure any ailment of the body politic," claims "Dr. Utopia," just like an old-time snake oil salesman. "Ism" offers something to workers, manufacturers and politicians, and to farmers, well, "Ism even makes the weather perfect every day."
The salesman asks his audience to make this pledge: "I hereby turn over to Ism, Incorporated, everything I have, including my freedom, and the freedom of my children, and my children's children, in return for which said Ism promises to take care of me forever." This doesn't scare them. So onlooker "John Q. Public" urges them to get better acquainted with the enemy.
"Before signing up, you boys ought to try a little taste of Dr. Ism's formula to see what you'd get in exchange for your 'freedom.' Go ahead! Try it." They drink and are plunged into a totalitarian dream. Clamped inside the State's iron fist, the worker cannot strike and is no longer protected by his union. The manufacturer is now irrelevant. "No more private property. No more you!" the State says to manufacturer, kicking him out onto the street. The farmer is controlled through a central production plan and turned into an industrialized employee of the state. One courageous politician speaks up for freedom, but is quickly brainwashed, becoming "State Propaganda speaker 3120," a phonograph where his head should be, saying "Everything is fine!" over and over again.
The Sloan Foundation lets John Q. Public have the last word. "When anybody preaches disunity," Mr. Public says, "tries to pit one of us against the other through class warfare, race hatred, or religious intolerance, you know that person seeks to rob us of our freedom and destroy our very lives. And we know what to do about it!" In a hail of his tonic bottles, Dr. Utopia is chased away and flees towards a glowing city. Apparently John Q. Public didn't believe in the First Amendment.
Business Screen, the organ of the sponsored film industry, liked these films but warned employers to pull their punches. Ò...Many companies have initiated regular programs of noon-hour and off-shift film showings....This is by no means an invitation to propagandize. These voluntary employee audiences are fair-minded Americans whose interest and enthusiasm places a direct responsibility upon the program planner. The fact that movies have a favorable psychological effect in relieving boredom and strain is rewarding in itself. If a good film program can inculcate ambition and greater productivity to earn a deserving higher wage, that is certainly the desirable objective. Films are no substitute for a raise.Ó (Business Screen, April 1949).
But Roger Spottiswoode was much less favorable. In his review (included on this disc) he criticized Make Mine Freedom for its "hatred of foreigners, a contempt for their way of life, and an attempt to bigotry and intolerance at home." "The whole unpleasant dish," he stated, "is served up with a crude but appealing humor, calculated to lull an audience into a receptive frame of mind."
Labor fought business's media offensive through whatever means it could mobilize: its own press, radio programs, publications and union and community meetings. Unions produced a number of films that challenged corporate points of view, but these were not shown in theaters and on TV as the Harding College pictures were. Backed by business's economic clout, corporate messages were louder and successfully manipulated public opinion away from liberal and labor-oriented ideas and towards perspectives more harmonious with business.
Ken Smith notes: The first and best of the Harding College "Fun and Facts About America" cartoon series. A sleazy salesman tries to sell bottles of "Ism" to a union worker, businessman, farmer, and politician, promising them that they'll had everything they desire once they swallow it. And, incidentally, once they sign a paper giving up their "freedom". Great footage of a giant, hairy, green monster hand of "the state" grabbing these foolish Americans and subjecting them to all manner of indignities. Funded by Alfred P. Sloan, who knew about big fists.
GREAT anti-communist PROPAGANDA
entirely animation; ostensibly (scummy) patriotic film which shows us the capitalist good guys and the socialists who wish to enslave us all.
malt shop and couple dancing to jukebox; grandpa sleeping on front porch; family in church pews; man golfing badly; tycoons on Wall Street with big cigars; men sitting around Franklin stove; racially mixed classroom; man building skyscraper; two men verbally arguing; man mowing lawn; men in jury box wolf whistle at woman on the stand; man in convict's stripes in jail; ballot box; exterior of church; Statue of Liberty;
arguing between labor and management; snake oil salesman;
light bulb over man's head; man tinkering in workshop; man driving early automobile and crashing;
money: gold coin; greenbacks under the mattress and sack of money with $ symbol on it dug up from the ground;
how savings were used from family to buy tools and property: capitalism
racist caricatures of people of other nations and how they don't stack up financially to Americans in per capita income;
cloverleaf traffic pattern;
in socialist the government is symbolized by giant blue and moving pushing people around; man in barbed wire camp labeled state concentration camp #5.
"When anybody preaches disunity, tries to pit one of us against the another through class warfare, race hatred or religious intolerance, you know that person seeks to rob us of our freedom and destroy our very lives. And we know what to do about it." [At this point a mob brandishes bottles at "ISM" salesman threateningly; he begs for mercy; they disregard him and throw the bottles anyway. Cut to scene of the Lincoln Memorial and patriotic music.]
[Rick, I have never seen anything like this where the superego tells the mob to murder a socialist and the mob joins in happily]
Animation Cartoons Economics Capitalism Anti-communism Cold War
[This is one of a series of films produced by the Extension Department of Harding College to create a deeper understanding of what has made America the finest place in the world to live.]
[Harding College presents Make Mine Freedom, color by Technicolor. A John Sutherland Production. animated cartoons animation art cards title cards graphic design Statue of Liberty]
America is many things to many people. To a seventeen-year-old kid, it's the malt shop on the corner. To Grandpa, it's the front porch in the cool of the evening. To Mother and her family, it's church on Sunday morning. And to Dad, it's his favorite relaxation. [juke boxes jukeboxes jitterbugging dancing religion golf leisure recreation]
It's the cracker-barrel philosophers in Crabtree Corners and it's the tycoons in Wall Street. It's all races, creeds, and religions. It's freedom to work at the job you like, freedom of speech and to peaceably assemble.
Freedom to own property. Security from unlawful search or seizure. "Where's your warrant, flatfoot?" [lawn mowers bill of rights policemen]
The right to a speedy and public trial, protection against cruel punishments and excessive fines, the right to vote and to worship God in your own way. [wolf whistles blondes sexism prisons prisoners convicts ballot boxes voting elections padlocks churches]
It is these freedoms that have made America strong. "Okay, okay so we got our freedom, but management's lousin' up everything." "Labor is at fault. It's ruining the country." "My constituents, as your elected representative, I can assure you labor's right, management's right. [Statue of Liberty arguments dissension differences of opinion]
I'm strictly neutral." "Labor, management, politicians? Phooey! Well, they can't tell corn from oats." "Hurry, hurry - step right up folks. Here's the answer to your problems. Dr. Utopia's sensational new discovery - ISM. [farmers tonics nostrums arguments snake oil salesmen snake-oil quacks]
ISM will cure any ailment of the body politic. It's terrific. It's tremendous. Once you swallow the contents of this bottle, you'll have the bountiful benefit of higher wages, shorter hours, and security. Enormous profits, no strikes. Remember you're the big boss. Government control, no worry about votes. Name your own salary. Bigger crops, lower costs. Why, ISM even makes the weather perfect every day.
And now then, because we are introducing this amazing item for the first time in this country, it isn't going to cost you one cent. All you have to do is sign this little scrap of paper and you'll get your bottle absolutely free."
I hereby turn over to ISM Incorporated everything I have including my freedom and the freedom of my children, and my children's children, in return for which, said ISM promises to take care of me forever. "I'll take two bottles." [Dr. Utopia's Ism bulls agreements contracts nose rings noserings bullshit]
"Pardon me, pardon me." "And who are you, my good man?" "I'm John Q. Public." "Ah, my fine friend. You're just in time to share this generous and gigantic offer. Sign right here." "Hmmm, mind if I read it first?
Keep your shirts on, boys. Including my freedom - Freedom? Sign away my freedom? Why this is ridiculous!" "Don't be corny, brother. Ha, ha, ha, ha." "Sure our system of free enterprise isn't perfect, but before we throw it away for some imported doubletalk let's turn the clock back a few years to see what it's done for us.
For example back in the 1890's, Joe Doakes was just a guy who liked to tinker around his barn. Some people thought Joe was lazy. Some even thought he was nuts. But one day he had an idea. [Joe Doakes stable carriages craftspeople inventors creativity innovation]
And because he was free to dream his dream and tinker, Joe had a chance to make something of himself and his idea. So - [transportation motorized bicycles]
Of course some people didn't think so much of Joe's idea. But that didn't stop him. [accidents crashes]
So Joe got some money from young Aunt Minnie and Uncle Angus and Grandpappy and Mr. Titus. When Joe's friends and relatives used their savings to help him buy tools and property they were capitalists. [investors investments blushing embarrassment]
Don't blush, folks. It's nothing to be ashamed of. Now naturally, Joe needed some help. So he hired Willy Lumpkin who was out of work anyway, and before long Willy had the know-how and became skilled labor.
Because capital, management, and labor work together, Joe's idea grew. It grew and did things even he never dreamed of. Today the automobile industry provides millions of jobs that never existed before. [expansion growth factories signs]
And remember this is a story of only one industry. There are thousands more scattered all over the United States whose history of development is pretty much the same.
We've built a country under the American system that sends more young people to high school and college than all the rest of the world combined. [children]
Why even in the Depression our wages bought more food, clothing, travel, and entertainment than the wages of any other people in the world. Our country has a national income equal to the total national incomes of any other six nations in the world.
With only seven percent of the Earth's people, we drive seventy percent of the world's automobiles. That's just a sample of the things the capitalistic system has given us in only one hundred and sixty years. [freeways cloverleafs 160 capitalism land use highways interchanges]
Before signing up, you boys ought to try a little taste of Dr. ISM's formula to see what you'd get in exchange for your freedom. Go ahead. Try it."
"You can't do this to me. I'll strike." "The state forbids strikes. " "Wait 'til the union hears about this." "Ah yes, the union. Welcome to our ranks number 1313." [workers labor slavery iron fists]
"I'll take this case to the Supreme Court." "The state is the Supreme Court. Our decision is as follows: No more private property. No more you." [capitalists expropriation of industry giants giant fists]
"Well the farm folk'll put a stop to this." "Farmers don't vote anymore." "Well, what will they do for seed next year?" "You won't have to worry about next year. The state will do your planting from now on." [kulaks]
"We must fight to regain our freedom or everything is lost. Everything . . ." "Everything is fine. Everything is fine. Everything is fine. Everything is fine. Everything is fine." [State concentration camp 5. State propaganda speaker 1320 phonographs victrolas repetition]
When anybody preaches disunity, tries to pit one of us against the other through class warfare, race hatred, or religious intolerance, you know that person seeks to rob us of our freedom and destroy our very lives. [demagoguery demagogues]
And we know what to do about it. "Now gentleman. No violence please. Don't throw those bottles. Don't throw those bottles." [vigilantism mob action mobs riots Emerald City shining cities]
"Working together to produce an ever greater abundance of material and spiritual values for all. That is the secret of American prosperity." [The End. From sea to shining sea American flags Lincoln Memorial parades patriotism fife and drum]
- 2002-07-16 00:00:00
- Closed captioning
- United States
- Run time
Subject: Usage License
Subject: Awesome cartoon
First off, THERE ARE NO "POLITICAL LEADERS"! There are only REPRESENTATIVES and public SERVANTS. We are the ones who elect these assholes into their artificial positions of power to SERVE us. They aren't our fuckin' leaders and never will be unless people continue to act like a flock of stupid sheep and turn a blind eye while these lying bunch of corporate/political weasels try to pass illegal legislation to chip away our rights and make themselves more powerful. In school, you should have learned that the Founding Fathers put in place a system of checks and balances to limit what powers the government has: the president can veto bills passed through Congress, Congress can override a presidential veto, and the courts can declare laws unconstitutional, but the thing they don't tell you as that absolute final authority lies with the people! If there is a law or set of laws which a majority of the people find outrageous, immoral, unjust, and/or oppressive WE THE PEOPLE can stand up and make it clear that we won't stand for it. If our elected REPRESENTATIVES aren't doing their jobs or dare to push legislation that we find intolerable we have the power to stand up and say "HELL NO!!" Recently, the "Supreme Court" ruled that Americans cannot sue the government for the unconstitutional surveillance of the NSA Prism, but WE THE PEOPLE have the right and need to stand up and say "FUCK NO! We Won't Tolerate This Shit!"
Nobody on Capitol Hill has more authority in this country than WE THE PEOPLE! That's why the fuckin' constitution begins in big letters "WE THE PEOPLE". To quote the 10th Amendment, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." To put it simply, the federal government and everybody in it is our bitch! So we need to start pimp-slappin' some motherfuckers who aren't doing their damn jobs!
Subject: The Best John Sutherland Capitalism Cartoon
Subject: Drinking the Kool Aid
Some one says we should read history OK lets step back in time...
If Freedom is so bad why did the Boat People flee the communist take over of Viet Nam? Many did not make it. We will never know how many thousands died. Why did so many die trying to escape from behind the Iron Curtain?
If communism is so wonderful why did "Peoples Republics" murder in one way or another over 100 million of their own citizens in the 20th Century.
If capitalism does not work were did the 300000 aircraft come from that the US made in WW-II?? How did the Pacific Fleet rise from the wreckage of Pearl Harbor to be larger than any 2 other NAVYS on the planet in less than 4 years? Why were there so many aircraft from CAPITALIST (free) countries being flown by Russian's on WW-IIs eastern front? (30% of the Soviet Air Force was British and American Aircraft this from a surviving German fighter pilot Gunter Rahls)
Finally where would the world be today if American manufacturing had been scattered about the world (in many cases to our sworn enemies) in 1938 as it is today?
Socialism/Communism does not work. Look at a night time satellite image of the Korean Peninsula for confirmation. Does anyone wonder why North Korea is so dark?
Communism was first tried in America by the PILGRIMS. This was why they damned near starved. The Natives did not save them CAPITALISM DID. LOOK IT UP. The people that could work and produce were forced to feed the people that would not/could not and they basically quit working too. Putting fish in the garden for fertilizer was common in Europe BTW. But we are not told of the fundamental change that ultimately saved them. Now we are changing back to what they had to abandon to survive. WAKE UP!
We have be propagandized for DECADES by school teachers, the "news media", film makers and any place else the Marxist/Leninist/Communist types could insinuate themselves to do what Khrushchev told us would happen. But the USSR has not subjugated us we have done it to ourselves by not paying attention. By voting in people whose prime interest was to make us all wards of the state.
The greatest damage came with FDR being able to appoint leftist leaning Supreme Court justices THE WHOLE COURT eventually. They gutted the Constitution in the late 1930s early 40s and we have never recovered. THIS is where the Nanny state and Federal Control of every facet of your life comes from. Read Madison's take on the Constitution or any of the others that worked it all out. If it does not say the Gov't can do it them the Gov't CANNOT DO IT. But NOW we are told that if its not specifically banned the Gov't can do it. This is 180 degrees from the intent of the people who wrote the original document. LOOK IT UP.
Even worse we are increasingly becoming wards of the UN via treaties. Look carefully at the UNs statement of human rights. You have all sorts of rights under the UN. Unless your rights interfere with something the gov't (UN) wants to do.
How about FDRs ongoing state of emergency that gives the Gov't wide spread powers and basically makes the Constitution a dish rag? Does anyone here know of this unrepealed power grab by the Executive branch? They did not tell you about it in Civics class? LOOK IT UP. There are hundreds of pages of primary source documents on the Constitution. The Federalist papers and the Anti-Federalist writings. Its ALL out there. But what is put down here, prior to ratification, is "inconvenient" to a great many who work for "change".
If the SCOUS gives a green light to Obamacare guess who will come around to make sure you get properly signed up. The IRS.
I hope the Kool Aid flavored "ism" tasted good, cause its sure not good for you.
BTW history has shown that McCarthy was right...
But the leftists and dupes in the "news media" didn't like him so now the threat of Communism expounded by McCarthy is called a "witch hunt". Except in this case the "witch" was far too real.
Subject: Great cartoon.
Subject: To FreedomBrigade
Subject: Its not about you or me its about we (past, present, and future)
Subject: Life imitates art..
Subject: mrfreedombrigade is confused
Republican Congress = up economy
Democrat Congress = Downward economy...
When mixed we see a slower downward economy...
Put God back in schools.
Put Money into the Peoples pocket.
Put power back to the States.
Then America will see the Liberty and freedom we have enjoyed for years...
Subject: It's about FREEDOM, not Capitalism!!
Subject: Make mine CORPORATE POWER
Corporate America gets credit for everything good in American life, but the cartoon glosses over that such prosperity as Americans had in 1948 depended upon despotic management, resource depletion, and cozy relations between government and business. No mention is made of the severe inequality implicit in Jim Crow practices. Sixty years later, when American capitalism has approached dystopian reality, "Make Mine Freedom" would be a ludicrous conception because workers -- blue-collar and white-collar alike, and struggling farmers and small business owners, have become veritable thralls of plutocrats and tycoons who see any people other than themselves and their loved ones expendable, and the resources of the Earth merely objects to process for quick profits.
Subject: then versus now
Subject: Make Mine Freedom (1948)
No house on the hill in the country and big yard. AAAHHH Piss on your socialism guvmnt run everything. Hi I'm from the government ,,I'm here to help. Stay out of MY life and get one yourself PAWN
Where NIXON when you need him dammit!! LOL
Just venting, liked the film very entertaining.
Subject: Evil Empire Vs. Freedom Empire
Subject: Did anyone else notice...
The voice artist for the seller of ISM is Frank Nelson, who worked in cartoons, radio and television and did voiceovers for TV commercials.
Propaganda notwithstanding, this is an excellent example of late 40's Hollywood animation.
Subject: capitalism is not the perfect solution to all our needs
No, no and no!
Now that we are capitalists, do we think that our world is the world we want to live? Unfortunately, no. Because capitalism becomes successful, we have destroyed and exploited billions of lives worldwide. We became more selfish and superficial and our world is becoming more and more corrupt. We don't care very much about ourselves more than we shouldn't be. We could consider ourselves well-off, but look on the other side of the world and we realize that we're simply not.
Capitalism is a very evil system. It encourages us to cheat everything, from money to labor to our morals. Instead of distributing freedom to all of us, we take away more of the lower classes' independence not knowingly that we are also controlled by the higher class. That is why that film does not make sense at all. In some parts, it disguises as a friend to everyone. Luckily, the earlier parts shows its greedy side. Hah!
Subject: Not about capitalism versus communism
Lies, lies, lies....
Oh, meatpies...as long as one is honest one need not fear the judgement of history. Certainly it's fair to criticize this kind of garbage---lies are lies no matter how old they may be. Of course, patriotism based on the "my country right or wrong" attitude has to rely on lies---truth would shatter it.
Subject: Communism just won't work...
Capitalism has it's flaws, too... but at least we can work hard and see the fruits of our labor. I have a nice, but not NEW car. I love it. I shop at Walmart if I want, and I get my coffee from a mom and pop shop if I want. I have the freedom to do so. I make hand-crafted items for homeless people, because I want to love everyone.
I felt this cartoon was patriotic for it's time. Is it fair to look back and ridicule something over 50 years old? If so, then let's determine what's going to happen 50 years from now and ridicule ourselves for how we're acting, even though we feel it's right for our time now, because it won't be 50 years from now.
Subject: I saw this in grade school
Subject: Disney menality leads Disneyized minds
Dwindle is a mouth on a stick, and a sure product of the failed American schools system. A bunch of twaddle about Europe passes for analysis.
Socialism never fails because it's impossible to plan an economy or because it presses upon freedom (that idea claimed by teary-eyed Americans), rather its philosophical core asks too much of essentially simple beings who could never live up to such impossibly high ideals. This said, that impossibility is hijacked by the people with a cess-pool morality and the drones who believe them, to peddle everything up to Friedmanite murderous economics (think Argentina and Pinochet), destroy civil society, and to get away with it.
Well-made cartoon technically; simple-minded blather as the message.
Although it sometimes seems to make us think that unions are bad and employers should be able to treat their workers however they want.
Subject: comunism would rock!
Subject: Make My Freedom or take it
Communism is an ideology that seeks to establish a classless, stateless social organization based on common ownership of the means of production. It is usually considered a branch of the broader socialist movement that draws on the various political and intellectual movements that trace their origins back to the work of Karl Marx.
"The Communists... are on the one hand, practically, the most advanced and resolute section of the working-class parties of every country, that section which pushes forward all others; on the other hand, theoretically, they have over the great mass of the proletariat the advantage of clearly understanding the lines of march, the conditions, and the ultimate general results of the proletarian movement.
The immediate aim of the Communists is the same as that of all other proletarian parties: formation of the proletariat into a class, overthrow of the bourgeois supremacy, conquest of political power by the proletariat." - Karl Marx, Communist Manifesto, 1848
Subject: Great cartoon
As for many of you that support socialism or communism I think you misunderstand our societies problems. One of the main problems, just as deadly is corporatism. Small business will never be a threat to society because they are owned by families and are local. But big international business is a huge threat to our welfare.
A state controlled economic system will always fail. Why? Because like physics for every action taken in a market there is an equal reaction. It might take time like the ripples of waves but that is the reaction spreading through the system.
The real problems are the centralized Federal Reserve, globalized Wall Street and subsidies for big business that protects the wealthy from competition or supports foreign cheap labor investment. In many ways America has become a fascist or communist state through maintaining these institutions and redistributing the wealth of America’s labor to foreign nations.
Communism will always fail because they attempt to control the marketplace. Just as our current corporatist society will fail too. If you want communism and it’s sibling socialism to work it will happen only when people want to live in peace with each other and we have evolved into a species that has no need for a barter system. As long as we trade and own property capitalism will live on. We just need to get the super wealthy corporate leadership out of our government and soon.
Interesting also that our own government has become the traveling salesman selling ism for our freedom in the name of security. As I get older it becomes far truer that anyone who attempts to divide us is a conqueror with ulterior motives.
Liberty is the most important asset we have. It should never be sold in the name of economics, security or religion. With liberty we have all of those, but without we lose all of them. That is what the message was and it is totally correct, propaganda or not.
Subject: Capitalism is a total failure.
Subject: John Doakes III
I'm teaching in China (where everything is made now) as they move from CommunISM to CapitalISM. It bothers me how in this transition, many of my students are moving from the comradery of SocialISM to greed of MaterialISM.
* I'm waiting to go to Sydney on R&R, and plan to see the movie "Who Killed the Electric Car?" ... and Star Wars III in English...
We have every right to implement free healthcare, minimum wages, corporate controls, et el. But time and time agan, we reject theose proposals. Massachusetts for example is implementing state wide healthcare for everyobdy, free for the poor. But then again, they tried that 20 years ago and rejected it then, too.
You shouldn't feel bad for Americans, not when we make, on average, $20,000 a year more than the average European, nor should you feel bad for ethnic minorities - hispanics for example are starting their own businesses three times faster than the American average. That mean a Mexican living in America is 5 times more likely to own his own business than a European.
Bush doesn't control America, neither do the corporations. No one in America can do anything without our consent. We could shut down Walmart tomarrow, or make the minimum wage $15 an hour for all we care.
But we see Europeans working for pathetically low wages, paying absurd taxes, being ruled over by the state, hell, most of you don't even have a jury of your peers. The government decides your innocence.
This movie illustrated why Americans have chosen freedom over the false promises of socialism time and time again, and why almost every other nation in the world is following in our footsteps.
Subject: This actually made me quite sad.
Subject: very strange ... especially today
the patriot act: what would john q public say about that?
"the freedom to work where you want" off course, all those ethnic young people are doing their 2 or 3 lousy paid partime jobs at walmart or mc donalds out of their free will !!? don't think so.
off course, the stalinist system in the ussr from 1924 till 1990 and those other totalitarian freaks like hitler, poll pott and mao weren't the number one alternative for the people, but this movie glorifies capitalism (notice the ISM!) in a perverse way because people today in the us (and also in many countries in europe) are losing their freedoms and their wealth due to capitalism and imperialism.
Subject: Want some ISM?
Subject: I just love propaganda! Heh
Uploaded by Unknown on